My Brother Owes Me $6K. Ought to I Forgive the Debt or Sue Him?


Expensive Penny,

My brother owes me over $6,000, and he’s taking ceaselessly to pay it off. He owes cash to banks as properly. Would it not be higher to damage our relationship and take him to court docket or simply forgive the debt? 

It’s some huge cash, and he has owed it to me for fairly numerous years now. Do you’ve another recommendations of recoup that cash?


Expensive Irritated,

Let’s put apart the connection for a second. Do you assume your brother has $6,000 sitting round someplace and is refusing to pay you? Or is it likelier that he’s flat broke and also you’re simply one of many many individuals he owes?

Many individuals imagine the parable that efficiently suing somebody means you’ll truly get cash. That’s merely not true. Even if in case you have stable proof your brother owes you (which regularly isn’t the case with household and buddies) and also you win a court docket judgment, that judgment is nugatory when the particular person you’ve sued is broke.

Bought a Burning Cash Query?

Get sensible recommendation to your cash challenges from Robin Hartill, a Licensed Monetary Planner and the voice of Expensive Penny.

DISCLAIMER: Choose questions will seem in The Penny Hoarder’s “Expensive Penny” column. We’re unable to reply each letter. We reserve the correct to edit and publish your questions. However don’t fear — your id will stay nameless. Expensive Penny columns are for basic informational functions solely, however we promise to offer sound recommendation based mostly on our personal analysis and insights.

You could possibly ask for a court docket order to garnish his checking account, however that received’t do you any good if there’s no cash in there. Plus, if he owes banks cash for issues like adverse balances and overdraft charges, he may not actually have a checking account.

Perhaps you would get a wage garnishment order in case your brother is employed. However federal regulation usually limits that quantity to 25% of somebody’s disposable earnings, so in case your brother doesn’t make loads, this will likely not yield a lot. Additionally understand that some kinds of earnings, like Social Safety, are off-limits from creditor claims.

In lots of states, $6,000 is throughout the threshold for small claims court docket, so that you most likely wouldn’t should pay a lot in court docket prices. But additionally think about the worth of your time. You could possibly find yourself losing many hours and nonetheless stroll away with nothing — whereas nonetheless destroying the connection together with your brother within the course of.

Take into consideration how probably it’s that your brother can afford to repay you. Does he spend cash on holidays, hobbies and going out to eat? In that case, go forward and sue your brother. Give him a last warning or two first. Perhaps attempt sending him a requirement letter through licensed mail stating your intent to sue if he doesn’t pay up. On this situation, I wouldn’t be so frightened about making a rift.

Somebody who intentionally stiffs you out of $6,000 clearly doesn’t worth the connection.

However for those who assume your brother is struggling, have a chat with him and ask him to be practical. Does he ever see himself getting caught up sufficient to repay you? I’m positive you’ve most likely had this dialog far too many occasions to depend by now. However possibly for those who provide some versatile options, you’ll be able to recoup at the least a few of that cash.

Might he afford funds of $50 or $100 a month? If he has a checking account and he agrees to this, ask him to arrange computerized transfers.

You may additionally borrow a transfer from skilled debt collectors and provide to forgive a number of the debt he owes in trade for a lump sum. Since he owes you $6,000, you would inform him that if he will pay $3,000, you’ll forgive the opposite half. Once you’re speaking a few debt that’s been lingering for a number of years, gathering something is healthier than nothing.

I’d additionally let him know that suing him is one thing you’ve thought of. Inform him that’s a route you actually don’t need to go since you care concerning the relationship — but additionally that if you lent him the $6,000, you actually believed he’d repay you.

The necessary factor right here is to be practical. When you don’t imagine your brother will ever have the funds to repay you, I believe forgiving this debt is the best choice. That is as a lot for you as to your brother.

Once you’re holding onto the hope that one thing will occur, you wind up annoyed each time it doesn’t. Generally the perfect factor you are able to do is transfer on. Plus, accepting the truth that you’re by no means getting that $6,000 again helps you propose your individual funds higher.

In fact, forgiving isn’t forgetting. Don’t ever lend your brother cash once more. And for those who ever lend cash to somebody sooner or later, do it with the idea that you just received’t be repaid.

Robin Hartill is an authorized monetary planner and a senior author at The Penny Hoarder. Ship your tough cash inquiries to [email protected].


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here